- Abyss Watchers
- Ashen One*
- Aldrich, Saint of the Deep
- Lothric, Younger Prince**
- Ludleth of Courland
- Soul of Cinder***
- Yhorm the Giant
† This is dependent on the meaning of Sweet Shalquoir's dialogue; specifically the line of: "The Lost Sinner lives deep within the bastille. The fool. Trying to light the First Flame…"
* Depending on the player's chosen endings, the Chosen Undead and Ashen One could all be considered Lords of Cinder. The Bearer of the Curse's status after choosing to assume the Throne of Want is unknown, and as such it isn't clear if they even attempted to Link the Fire let alone became a Lord of Cinder.
** It is implied that Lothric never actually linked the fire despite being destined to. Instead, he chose to watch from a distance as the fire faded.
*** The Soul of Cinder is a deific manifestation of the previous Lords of Cinder.