Unsurprising given that a lot more people have played Elden Ring than any other game (though I am surprised The Old Hunters got that relatively high, given that the game is locked to PS4). Quite surprised that none of the Lost Crowns trilogy are there, given that they are often considered the best parts of DS2.

My favorite is The Ringed City so it is somewhat painful to see it that low.

Shadow of the erdtree is so big that it’s basically its own game so I get why ppl like it the most

However, there is also recency bias