Board Thread:Wiki Discussion/@comment-5264386-20141113101121/@comment-6947637-20141118220441

I have some additions I'd like to suggest/discuss.

Links

Should links to other Dark Souls wiki sites (wikidot, fextralife etc) also be prohibited? They can cause confusion among visitors. I know someone added such a link to an article the other day which was taken down shortly afterwards.

Editing

Should the editing of other users' profiles be prohibited? As I mentioned in a previous comment there seems to be an unspoken agreement among users to refrain from doing this, but in the interests of covering ourselves in case someone comes along, messes with people's profiles claiming "there's nothing that says I can't do it".

Policies and Guidelines

"Refusal to follow these policies is prohibited"

IMHO this sounds like circular logic i.e. it's not allowed because it's not allowed. Maybe it would be better to mentioned the consequences of non-adherance?

The next logical step then would be to include a section on the punishment system. What should be severity of the punishment for breaking each individual policy be? How will punishment increase with repeat offences? etc etc.