Thread:Cosmicsilver/@comment-24886111-20141201101311/@comment-5632187-20141202032135

In order to obtain the trophy, the required weapons must be in the player's inventory. And even if Nier had held a cursed weapon in his hand, that wouldn't register as the Cursed GS of Artorias, he'd have to have that specific weapon in his inventory. I will test the list currently posted w/o the Cursed GS, and if I get the trophy then I'll restore Nier's edit which denotes that only one is required, not both.

Also, this file doesn't seem to be an official FromSoftware doc, so it can definitely be inaccurate. But I'll get back to you with my findings, until then I guess the page should stay as it is.