Talk:King's Mirror/@comment-172.56.16.72-20140722082514/@comment-98.250.190.229-20140804080653

It's not really a theory you made up; it's common sense. Yours is a replica of a weapon, and you're not the original wielder. Regardless of whatever the original shield's properties or origins are, the player's shield is not that, so of course it's weaker.