Talk:Chaos Blade (Dark Souls II)/@comment-25433835-20141104172617/@comment-4511886-20141104180231

It was a popular, and fairly iconic, weapon in DaS. That's more than enough reason. It is also by far the best option of returning items from the Witch of Izalith.

The Izalith Catalyst would be irrelevant, as pyromancy didn't turn into sorceries/casted with staves (as was initially planned) and Quelaag's Fury Sword is obviously Quelaag's sword, not the witch's. The Demon's Catalyst is unrelated to her, and no other items are available that is related to her or the Daughter's of Chaos.