Talk:Majestic Greatsword/@comment-68.104.252.45-20140904230354/@comment-16047389-20140915211224

The Abyss Greatsword isn't a replica, it IS the sword Artorias used. The item description doesn't say "this is a replica of the weapon Artorias used", it flat out states "This greatsword belonged to Lord Gwyn's Knight Artorias, who fell to the abyss."

Find an item ascended from the very soul of its original master that says it is a replica of the original, and you might be able to get away with that theory. But there's some things that you can't refute. First, when Artorias and his weapon "disolve", as you put it, the Chosen Undead ends up with Artorias's soul within their possession. The soul is used to ascend another weapon into the Abyss Greatsword. And finally, the Abyss Greatsword you make states not once, but TWICE that the weapon now in your hands is, in fact, the very same sword that Artorias used.

Find this evidence with which you claim the Abyss Greatsword is infact a replica. Otherwise, the very premise is more speculative than the idea that Artorias was left-handed.