Board Thread:Dark Souls/@comment-11991696-20130711220139/@comment-11227880-20131105133001

AWC, your review on his theory was pretty blunt. Have some heart and acknowledge he went to the trublec to piece his own explanation and speculatory theory together.

Your theory is interesting and while there is a good deal of lore, evidence and speculation to justify he is the firstborn, there is an equal number of conflicting evidence to suggest he isnt the firstborn. One of those conflicting evidence is the Developer at From Soft saying that the firstborn is not in Dark Souls at all, while Solaire is. Its hard to know which side is right, which is why im fence sitting until something makes this debate 'definite'.