Talk:Knight Artorias/@comment-24080141-20131113113001

SPECULATION:

I dont know if this has been mentioned before by anyone. (if it has, apologies for repeating)

Since there are a lot of time warping happening in DkS, there could be scenario where Arorias is present not as one entity but as three different ones, in three unique timelines.

In one timeline, he would be a faihful knight of gwyn and has his (awesome) greatsword with magical powers (scaling with Faith and Intel)

In one, he would be a dissident, goes down to meet Kaathe, gains a curse for his sword as well as the covenant ring.

In another, he could have just received a mail from Dusk to rescue her ( and got trapped by manus)

And hence we are able to get three vrsions of the same sword maybe because they are three different swords from three different timelines.