Talk:Shrine of Winter/@comment-24.197.50.88-20140328193119/@comment-69.49.208.58-20161122170329

You must have killed them. With all bosses, even optional, when you kill them, their souls count is automatically added to your Soul Memory. Even if you greedily crush them for Souls, or make them into a weapon.

What I am trying to say is that you don't have to keep them, because they add the full soul count (reward for beating them AND what you would get for their souls) when you kill them.

(P.S., when you kill the Duke's Dear Freja, you have to pick up her souls off of the ground.)