Board Thread:Dark Souls II/@comment-16047389-20140820175233

Let's say that FromSoftware decided to bring back one item (or set if applicable) from Dark Souls and add it to Dark Souls 2. The item would hold a similar nature to its predecessor counterpart, but may be remade so that its nature could apply in Dark Souls 2 (for example, since liquid humanity no longer exists, a Dark Hand may instead apply the Curse debuff, while restoring humanity to the user, or grant them a Human Effigy or something). The numbers on it may be rescaled in order to make it stronger, but it would not be made weaker (if it was overpowered in Dark Souls, it'd be overpowered here as well). The item would be worked into the game almost seamlessly, and would be placed in a location in a manner that meshed perfectly with already established lore (i.e. since the Darklurker's Soul posesses the ancient power of Lifedrain, Ornifex would be able to turn it into Dark Hand).

To decide which item(s) they'd be bringing over, they hold an open poll to the Souls community. The item may not be something that already exists in Dark Souls 2, or was functionally already replaced (such as how Human Effigy replaced Humanity).

What would be your item of choice and why? 