Talk:Four Knights of Gwyn/@comment-24786910-20140423003930/@comment-1265392-20140819223041

They are considered to be elites and a honorable title, so I don't think they needed to all do the same act to gain Gwyn's favor (for example, Ciaran likely did so with assassinations). They were probably estabilished after the war, all things considered. At that point, the kingdom of the gods in Anor Londo had likely existed for a while.