Board Thread:Lore Discussion/@comment-25615431-20150422094820/@comment-16047389-20150422145445

That theory only exists because people think his fashion sense is similar to the outfits of Bloodborne. Logically, it doesn't make any sense at all.


 * If Marvelous Chester was really from the Bloodborne universe, he would be using a gun and trick weapon. Not a crossbow.


 * Chester makes clear references to the current events of Oolacile being a known history to him ("Believe it or not, Oolacile has brought the Abyss upon itself.  Fooled by that toothy serpent, they upturned the grave of primeval man, and incited his ornery wrath.  What could they have been thinking?  But to you and I, it's all ancient history."), but we know that Dark Souls and Bloodborne exist in two entirely different realms of existence. He knows too much about the world in order to be from an entirely different one.


 * Chester was created before Bloodborne was even being actively developed. His style may have inspired the fashion for Bloodborne, or perhaps Chester was inspired by Miyazaki's early ideas for Bloodborne, but Chester existed before Yharnam was even a rough draft.


 * Additionally, not only is he from the current universe, but the time that he is from is also long before the events of Dark Souls 2. This is proven by the fact that he is able to identify several points of history and key figures (such as the cause of Oolacile's fall, and knowing Knight Artorias) that had been forgotten long before Drangleic was ever built.