Board Thread:Lore Discussion/@comment-4511886-20150329140746

Good day everyone. Today I thought about sharing a little nut I've been trying to crack for a while now, regarding Aldia.

As we all know, Aldia is the "Scholar of the First Sin" and while the scholar part is a given, what exactly "the first sin" was is not.

Personally, I think it has something to do with the First Flame. Perhaps the initiation of the cycle of light and dark or the Lords stealing the First Flame's power. We see what happened to Gwyn when he returned his soul to the flame, and you need all Lord Souls to enter the Kiln.

This is just speculation, but it's an interesting topic to discuss. So, if anyone has any other theories, feel free to share. 