Board Thread:Wiki Discussion/@comment-4028522-20140903033619/@comment-5264386-20140903073711

I'd argue that, whilst the Blue Smelter Demon may have different stats and aesthetics, the fact remains that there isn't enough to differentiate the two. The only way in which the two pages would arguably significantly vary is in the strategy section, and potentially boss information (should a formula to calculate enemy defences and attack ratings emerge).

However, this would pretty much be a case of one page saying "this one uses fire; use fire-blocking gear and spells" and the other "this one uses mainly magic, with a hint of fire; use gear and spells that blocks magic". In addition to this, regarding the boss information section, all it would really do is state that the Blue Smelter Demon has more stats because it's supposed to be a later-game boss than the original version.

@Cosmic: The fact that the Smelter Demon page would be classified as a DLC boss isn't really that much of a concern, as similar things have been done for the Murakumo (Dark Souls II) and Blacksteel Katana pages (since the special versions of these weapons were introduced to promote the DLC).

Therefore, given the above in conjunction with the fact that no unique gear or items are made available after defeating the Blue Smelter Demon, I vote that the pages are merged.