Board Thread:Wiki Discussion/@comment-5632187-20140906200338/@comment-16047389-20140922154812

Here's my thoughts on this.

The reasons I would have against this are that a Bloodborne Wikia already exists. It small, and undeveloped (as it would be this early on). It wouldn't seem right not to give it a chance to grow as our own wikia has. Demon's Souls also has a wikia, but it...well...it's pretty bad. I don't think the Demon's Souls community is nearly as strong, nor has ever been as strong, as the Dark Souls community. But it would just seem strange, and a little wrong, for this wikia to start adopting in other games (even if they are all spiritually relative to eachother), especially if their own wikias already exist and haven't been given ample oppurtunity to grow.

However, here's the other side of that argument. Most of Bloodborne's fanbase will probably be picked up from the Dark Souls community anyway, so it's not as if one community would actually be stealing a game from another. The "Souls Series" isn't just a fan-dubbed name. Even the devs considered Dark Souls to be a spiritual successor to Demon's Souls, and it sounds like they had the same idea about Bloodborne. The last point I would make on this area, is that unfortunately the Dark Souls community doesn't have an enormous amount of growth left in it. With Crown of the Ivory King being the last installment in the Lost Crowns trilogy, and the rather lack luster reception of Dark Souls 2, I don't see a future for Dark Souls 3. It's not the same as the Elder Scrolls series which has a sixth game to look forward to, and an entire MMORPG to keep them busy until then. Dark Souls 2 is likely the last game for the Dark Souls series, and it won't be long before the community growth stagnates, and eventually declines. We might be able to get a few months out of finishing up the Lost Crowns trilogy, but unless NamcoBandai has some undisclosed plan to continue the series, there is only so long this wikia would be able to last without new content.

TL;DR version: I don't think we should consider adopting in either Bloodborne (or Demon's Souls) into this wikia without giving their own wikias a chance to do so. Although, doing so would certainly bring in more users and content.