Board Thread:Dark Souls/@comment-179.98.177.213-20160623014621/@comment-74.131.203.139-20160718211130

This is an interesting theory. I don't think you are wrong as this makes perfect since too me in some ways. The one thing that does bother me is this: Solaire is a man of Faith, Faith being what one has when believing in the Gods and relying on the healing power of prayer and miricales to make it thru the tough times. Yet Solaires soul is trapped in the demon ruins which is basically Hell in Dark Souls. Solaire is to pure to deserve everlasting torment in Hell even if he did go insane and die there. (Unless you save him then he makes to the Kiln) Logan on the other hand is a man of intellect which according to his apperntice Griggs " Believes in no Gods only knowledge." So why would Logan's soul be in Duke, Duke being part of Anor Londo which is basically Heaven in Dark Souls. Logan does not deserve to live in paradise when he has no faith. Nor does Solaire deserve too suffer in Hell. If anything Logan should be in Hell for going against the Gods, Solaire should be in Heaven for his honor and Faith in the Gods. Anyway that's just my thought, I am not saying you are wrong in anyway I'm just sayin it sounds a bit backwards based off of their beliefs alone. But given where these characters die the theory makes perfect sense! Praise the Sun!!