Board Thread:Dark Souls/@comment-98.28.88.47-20130819010743/@comment-147.194.135.69-20140802164023

96.245.42.8 wrote: Here's a long shot, but here we go--Anastacia was implied to be some kind of 'heretic' by the crestfallen knight. Is it possible she spoke 'blasphemy' about Fina, and Lautrec, being the madman he is, felt exile was inadequate and set out to kill her? If he's that crazy and vindictive, it may explain why he took the firekeeper soul, yet didn't use it (a trophy). Not a particularly rational explanation, but Lautrec is a tried-and-true not-rational person.

I hate to be "that guy," but that idea gets shot down the instant you realize that Anastacia is mute until we revive her, so it's hard to swallow that she "spoke blasphemy" to Lautrec. What did she do, use sign language?