Talk:Old Witch Soul/@comment-180.249.205.143-20140406084948/@comment-178.183.4.97-20140408070110

I would think about this in terms of reincarnation. As in, even if a Lord soul is lost, it eventually reappears again. Lost Sinner might not be "physically" the Witch of Izalith, but she still has her soul, so she shares her knowledge, memories or simply "destiny" to an extent.

That, or people who made Dark Souls 2 were just a bunch of hacks who shoved in a bunch of references to the first game for a failed attempt at creating "depth" and the nostalgia factor. Who can tell!