Thread:HadAnd0426/@comment-24460960-20180527171509/@comment-24460960-20180528092815

You changed the page twice, removing my evidence each time.

There are multiple sources and you yourself have even acknowledged one. Anri's dialogue, the timing of the Unkindled waking up, the Darkmoon Bow description, the sound files and the general state of Gwyndolin himself. The movement he makes during the fight are pretty telling too. If you've ever watched his moves in slow-motion, which I have through Cheat Engine, you'll see that at the end of melee attacks, the body sags like a ragdoll at the end of the attack and it's pulled back up by the worm part of the boss.

You've also completely misunderstood part of my argument. I didn't say Aldrich couldn't feel pain. I said he wouldn't be feeling pain when he's sitting around doing nothing, if it was actually his body. I'll point to my sound evidence again; there are clear moans of pain you can hear when standing outside the gate of the boss room. Why would Aldrich be in pain if it was his body? He wouldn't. Those are moans of pain from Gwyndolin.

Nothing is ever simple in Dark Souls. You scoff at the notion that Gwyndolin changed his wardrobe, yet whole lands such as Anor Londo have clearly been changed heavily. If lands can be changed that heavily, then its really not ridiculous to suggest that characters can change how they look.

The Adlrich took on Gwyndolins form argument has absolutely no evidence to it whatsoever. Unlike my argument it literally has zero evidence backing it up. Nothing but fan-fiction. It was a notion that first came about when the game was new and no one had a clue what was going on. They just saw the "He slowly devoured Gwyndolin" description and took that very literally to mean that he'd already been fully eaten by the time we got there and so Aldrich must have taken his form. But that is not the case at all. There is no evidence for it.

I also asked these questions to you previously;

1. Why would Aldrich create a whole new body for himself when all it does is make him a better target?

2. How would he create all the clothes with such fine patterns along with the gold and why would he make the dress all tattered and ripped?

3. Why would he be moaning in paining while he's just sitting there doing nothing?

The Aldrich took on Gwyndolins form thing has absolutely nothing to back it up. As you have said; I've already been discussing this with people in the comments as well as the admins on the Discord server. No one has been able to provide any sort of shred of physical evidence to back them up. It literally is your definition of fan-speculation.

Like I said; there are things that are never outright stated in these games. Like the Nameless King being Gwyn's firstborn. That is never outright stated, but it's pretty obvious that he is the firstborn.

The Aldrich can change forms argument was never a real argument to begin with. It was a total guess with no evidence. Thank you for pointing out your Aldrich trivia.