Board Thread:Dark Souls II/@comment-10209824-20140506193921/@comment-98.250.190.229-20140907032532

Dark Jeto wrote: Dasvildanya wrote: Excuse me? If you are going to accuse me of this, please elaborate. Don't take that guy seriously, Dasvildanya. If you look at the majority of his contributions, all he really does on this site is complain and not really offer anything useful to a conversation. I probably would not have much to complain about if the discussions were actually intelligent and people honestly knew what they were talking about. And yes, Dasvildanya does spread misinformation. All you have to do is look at any lore discussion he's in.

The Lost Sinner is NOT the Witch of Izalith. She is, however, linked to her, but she herself is a separate being. Furthermore, Quelana, who was present when the Bed of Chaos was created, has outright stated the Bed ate up the Witch. So she was indeed dead around the time of the first game.