Talk:Gargoyle's Halberd/@comment-97.95.56.254-20140709053305/@comment-4511886-20140709060005

All halberds, except the Halberd itself, the Scythes (Great/Lifehunt only, not the "Scythe") and all halberds that are upgraded with Twinkling Titanite share an identical moveset. The Scythe is also harder to get, since the Gargoyle's Halberd is purely based on luck, while the Scythe has multiple hard hitting enemies on the to and from it. Also found later in the game.

This Halberd would be the better choice, since it has the same moveset, and more base damage at Fire +10.