Board Thread:Lore Discussion/@comment-25654683-20141110083826/@comment-25654683-20141115211505

Seath's Lord soul was a bequeathed Lord Soul shard as well. According to your theory, why wouldn't his shard reform with Gwyn's soul as well? I'm not trying to say that every soul reappears in the game, but everyone of the other Lord Souls did, including Seath's bequeathed Lord soul shard. I may be misunderstanding you, but you're trying to say that only the Lord Souls returned. But this is false. As a have said several times, Seath's soul was merely a shard of Gwyn's, and even Ornstein's soul is present. I agree with you, they did not all directly bring upon then ruin of their respective kingdoms. Yet, they were all still targeted by the Dark. This alone is a similarity between the old kings and the Four Kings of New Londo.

Much of the games Lore is filled with speculation, and fans filling in the blanks themselves. Even your own theories in this topic have bits of speculation. Well this is my own speculation on the Lore and connections I have made.