Talk:Greatsword of Artorias (Cursed)/@comment-50.149.28.119-20140305155026/@comment-25173123-20140827052026

I state on what is given me to go off of. If you have an actual chart showing the different scaling of each weapons letter coding then I would be glad to review it. As of now it shows that each has basically the same letter coding. Not identifying either as having a more powerful C then the other.

I am not ignoring the scaling. I place it as a normal progression of the weapon and identify that if you put much more stat increase to specific stats then you can create a niche use of many weapons over others.

I think what most people are saying is that they have scaled their character so high that they have basically eliminated the initial damage that BKS starts with. Which is possible but after a lot of leveling. And still requiring you to put dexterity into the forefront of the stat allocation. (as I already mentioned)

And yes I mentioned the Man-Serpent Greatsword already. Showing it has an A scaling for strength. Which does increase it's scaling quickly in that range. But a bit further down the line as you level up.

But you can't ignore dex completely from any build really unless you don't want to use anything but a single weapon. (which some people do... even I favor BKS over most while still using other weapons for specific battles.)

Can you say one sword is better then any other? No. But you can say that one sword does give you the better damage in the complete picture of NG. Now when you level up and move past a certain range then niche weapons will become more useful for many. Based on enemy fighting and your character build. But starting out and up to the end of NG... just has me pointing towards BKS being the weapon of choice that will get you much further through the first NG then any other Greatsword.

Is that an opinion? Sure is, but based off of average stats and leveling of players through normal game. Anything can be manipulated to make another weapon more powerful for them. But if you want to get a sword that can take you from start to finish in NG playthrough then BKS would be the Greatsword that makes it more efficient for most. Man-Serpent Greatsword has only even recently become viable for me to use it alongside BKS and I am ready to fight Gwyn now.