Talk:Aldia, Scholar of the First Sin/@comment-81.109.95.237-20150208133624/@comment-70.92.172.123-20150210100244

Maybe there's a story reason he doesn't give souls. He claims to be beyond death, completely removed from the cycle. Not even the Lords from the previous game could overcome the cycle, since you can still find their souls with their reincarnations. Maybe whatever process Aldia cooked up to 'free' himself obliderated his soul.