Board Thread:Dark Souls II/@comment-46.64.182.203-20140312230146/@comment-5633574-20140324041758

"The one to kill him in the Chosen Undead's timeline" is what I should have wrote. Though I find your immediate jumping to the "you don't understand the game itself" thing amusing. I'm well aware of how the game works in regards to different timeline and worlds, thank you, so your conclusion jumping is a touch unnecessary.

I'm not saying Solaire could not kill Gwyn, either. Gwyn is weak at that point in time; there aren't many people who couldn't kill him, provided they can reach him. Just that Solaire doesn't in the Chosen Undead's timeline. That being said, I haven't seen any evidence in either game that would support a reason for Solaire going to kill Gwyn, either.