Board Thread:Dark Souls II/@comment-24494913-20140319193521/@comment-184.5.186.240-20140407030313

Diafukkatsu,

I did not mean to imply that disagreement with the same as being antagonistic to. In fact as a general rule I have noticed that the forums on this wiki are quite civil for the most part. However tensions seemed to be running high and I included the last part as an attempt to keep the discussion from devolving into "F*&@ YOU, I"M RIGHT!" as I have seen happen in the past.

Also to clarify, when I said that giants may not be an organic species, I did not mean that they were not living beings. What I was trying to convey was that they may not be a naturally occuring species. If I recall there are a few creatures encountered in DS that are widely believed to have been created by Seathe through magic (Fantasy version of advanced genetic engineering), so perhaps the giants were also such a creation.

However the main point I was trying to make was that in the series there are many unanswered questions and very little solid evidence. That being the case, most of the theories being advanced have a chance to be true and so we as a community of players should be careful not to interchange our beliefs for evidence. In fact all theories that do not have directly contradicting evidence may at the same time be true and false, given that the loose form of storytelling used in the series allows every player to create a lore that is unique to, and true in, their copy of the games.