Talk:Titanite Slab/@comment-25940428-20150315092658

I let Sigmeyer jump down to the Chaos Eaters first and engage them. I had already picked off all but two of them with arrows beforehand, so he was in no danger. He didn't even take a hit. He said all the right things afterwards, demonstrating the quest wasn't broken at that point. I went to the Great Hollow and Firelink shrine, but couldn't find either him or her. As for Artorias, I had his soul and reloaded the level several times, entering and reentering as well. She never turned up. I definitely had the soul of Artorias with me, because when I checked out the sword you can make with it I discovered (not to my surprise), that it wasn't worth having (like most of the boss soul weapons). I didn't have a great deal of luck with the DLC actually, it took me at least three visits to get Gough to behave himself and offer to take down Kalameet.