Thread:Daifukkatsu/@comment-24390268-20140117062128/@comment-6003396-20140120081346

What articles exactly are you referring to? and thank you for asking this question. Many wikis keep speculation and opinions out of articles, not just this one. One reason why is illustrated well in the recent additions to Kirk's lore section:

"Kirk is assumed to have met his end at the hands of Quelaag or one of her servants as a corpse with his suit of armor can be found in her domain."

and later in a different paragraph:

"It is assumed that Kirk killed himself when he began to hallow so as to not be a threat to the Fair Lady. His actions prove that not all Dark Phantoms are irredeemably evil".

Two conflicting theories, and this is to be expected. Pages that are especially contested would have the potential to be filled with long explanations, alternate theories, counter arguments, etc. This would quickly clutter up the page and make it difficult to sort out the confirmed lore. And many are already familiar with the speculation to begin with, so is the wiki providing something useful by adding it? Speculation itself is fine and it does have a place; the forums and comments section are far better suited for it.