Talk:Oscar, Knight of Astora/@comment-70.79.77.121-20130502072236/@comment-5264386-20130502084248

It's a good theory, but it has its flaws:
 * 1) 1 True, his title is "Knight of Astora", but I fail to see the word "The" before "Knight of Astora". Just because he is a knight of Astora, doesn't make him the only knight.


 * 1) 2 "Exodus" is just another word in a very broad sentence. For example, "thou who art Undead, art Chosen". Quite clearly, this refers to more than one person being Undead, and we know there is a plague of Undeath in Lordran.

I highly doubt this saying is exclusive to Oscar's family, as well, since it sounds very prophetic. For all we know, many other Undead may have heard the prophecy, and may have escaped the Asylum in order to attempt to fulfill the prophecy.

Besides, the full quote says "in thine exodus from the Undead Asylum", not "in thine exidus from Astora". Oscar most likely didn't leave with a mass of Undead, as most of the Undead in the Asylum would have most likely been Hollowed, becoming worse than useless, even if they could be controlled.

So, just because you speculate something, doesn't make it proven.