Board Thread:Dark Souls II/@comment-2.223.169.191-20140325204725/@comment-88.131.105.133-20150422113314

This came to my mind while reading this.

What if The Lost Sinner is Magus Eygil, but the bug is the Witch of Izalith? Since the boss drops two souls, Old Witch Soul and Soul of The Lost Sinner.

Similar to Navlaan. Dark magic

The Witch enhanced the bug with a fragment of her soul, a failswitch if you like. If her atempt to rekindle the first flame would backfire, as it did. She could still exist with the fragment of her soul. And by posessing another powerfull pyromancers soul, as the bug. She would have "fooled" the cycle and could regain her power in a new cycle. This could explain her lack of pyromance, her powers had not manifested yet. And the shackles where bound to Magus Eygil and bound her powers aswell. A shackle Eygil plased on herself because of the great sin she did, then plased in her cell to be forgotten and became The Lost/Forgotten Sinner.

Btw, I did not laugh of the previous comment.