Board Thread:Dark Souls/@comment-11991696-20130711220139/@comment-11227880-20140111104850

Fault or no, it was there intention for the gamer playing Drk Souls to fill the gaps of the lore with his own imagination, to shape it by himself. Thus, if you spoil lore or spread it near and far than others shall follow suite in your acceptance of whatever speculative theory you churn up. For now, there is no definitive proof who is the firstborn, but the devs said in an interview the firstborn is not in Dark Souls, dead or alive. I see no reason why such threads still exist on the matter of andre, solaire or even Ornstein of being the firstborn.

Respect other's sense of imagination and just create a lore that fits your understanding. No one's right, no one's wrong. Move on.