Talk:Knight's Honor/@comment-3186827-20140729125207/@comment-216.54.8.243-20140819184639

Did you start your new character on a file right on top of your old character? There is the Bottomless Box glitch that any items in the box will transfer over to the overwritten character, which would explain it (it also transfers over other game info from what i've read, such as NPC status or obtained covenant levels). Otherwise I am not sure why it was not triggered for you, but what I do know for certain is I had every single weapon and shield listed for this achievement before ever crafting the Greatshield of Artorias, in this playthrough or any other, and it was not until I crafted that shield that I got the achievement.

This wikia is the only source to say the Greatshield of Artorias is not needed; every other source lists it as necessary. While it is relying on others' work instead of making my own, I would still trust the validity of their results as a backing to support this correction of information.

I left the strikethrough in there so that those who read the article before can visibly see the change in information.

As for adding it to the chart, I could not figure out how to remove the extra line going through the merged cell, which caused a visual oddity I did not care to introduce. As I was not able to figure out how to remove the line, short of trying to remake the entire table, I will leave it til I have more time, or until someone more talented at editing a Wiki comes along.