Talk:Lost Sinner/@comment-76.17.157.108-20140417193141/@comment-16047389-20140509191355

I do not agree with this theory.

First off, the Old Knights in Heide's Tower of Flame are far older than the Alonne Knights of Iron Keep, and they do not look that similar. The Old Knight wear a worn down thick green armor, while the Alonne Knights wear a shiny black steel. Additinally, the Alonne Knights were skilled marksman, and used light swift weapons, while the Old Knights used oversized heavy weapons. Additionally, while the Alonne Knights are known and have some lore attached, the Old Knights are, to quote the Old Knight Greatsword, " from a time so ancient that there exists no record of his endeavors."

The Lost Bastille existed back in Straid of Olaphis' time, which is likely older than the Iron Keep.

The only demons fought in game are Smelter Demon, Demon of Song, and Covetous Demon. Everything else is either undead, animated armor, or dragons. Covetous Demon used to be a man in love with Mytha and Demon of Song was kept imprisoned in the Shrine of Amana (once again, likely older than the Iron Keep).

If the deprevation of Light/Fire is part of her punishment, then why is the room fully lit BEFORE the fight? And what purpose is the Chaos Bug (because that is exactly what it is) that crawls into her eye?