Board Thread:Dark Souls/@comment-211.30.219.116-20140903113836/@comment-211.30.219.116-20140904234112

For the butcher's knife, I think the BASE damage is 1.1 * AR, while most other weapons are 1.0 * AR (for the scale of BASE that I'm using), so that might be what gives you the anomalies. For the great axe, if you're testing other weapons with AR around 572 and the greataxe still does more damage, that is weird. If you use the 1H jump attack for the manserpent greatsword (402 AR) and butcher's knife (352 AR) you should hit for around the same DMG as the greataxe.