Board Thread:Dark Souls/@comment-25173123-20140825050403/@comment-25173123-20140825110356

Totally understand your thoughts on that. But on the Wikia it normally is required to have information based on facts and not conjecture.

And yes if you think of it as a whole then it is only a portion of the lore. But having it read properly is what we are supposed to be striving for.

I myself believe that Gwyn's knights looked very similar to what the Silver Knights currently look like. But I don't see the Silver Knights gaining their identification until after they were assigned the duties of protecting the goddess and her having blessed them with her divine protection.

And the Black Knights obviously themselves formed from Gwyn's knights after being ashed but having none of the blessing of the goddess.